HbA1c May be Superior to FPG in Diagnosing Prediabetes
FPG (fasting plasma
glucose), HbA1c, and the OGTT (oral glucose
tolerance test) are used in determining if someone
has prediabetes or diabetes. Indeed, all three
measures are employed by the National Diabetes
Prevention Program (National DPP) to determine
eligibility for the National DPP. So, these blood
based tests are important, and understanding which
one of the three measurements is the most valid in
assessing prediabetes and diabetes is a worthwhile
undertaking. One recent
study has focused on determining the validity
of the measurements.
The OGTT is considered by some to be the gold
standard for diagnosing diabetes and prediabetes.
However, it is not always practical to perform the
test, and results are not always reproducible.
Therefore, while the OGTT is considered to be more
accurate for some high risk patients than the
HbA1c test, the HbA1c test is widely used since it
is more practical and it is considered to be a valid
test. So, determining how the test stacks up against
the FPG test is high on the priority list.
In the above mentioned study, 201 patients were
looked at. And the investigators concluded that
“HbA1c is a more
sensitive test compared to FPG in the
diagnosis of DM. Prospective studies with broad
participation at national and international levels
are needed to redefine HbA1c cut-off points for the
diagnosis of DM and prediabetes." When this is done,
"it will be possible to revise the diagnostic
guidelines accordingly.”
While work needs to be done in the area of defining
the cut-off points for HbA1c to improve the
diagnostic value of the measurement, the above study
does seem to indicate that engaging in additional
research to define the Hba1c cut-off points is worth
the effort.
Healthcare providers should pay attention to this
study and other studies related to diabetes and
prediabetes measurements. If we can increase the
validity of the measurements already in place, this
will lead to improved assessment of prediabetes and
diabetes. This endeavor will help providers deliver
more accurate assessments to patients, enabling
patients to take the appropriate actions.
-------------------------------------------------------
Tags: , ,